Write the brief around the decision you want made, the authority you will give to make it, and the number that will tell you whether it worked, in that order, and keep the list of channels for the appendix. The reason is in the tenure data. Spencer Stuart’s January 2026 study of 346 named CMOs across the S&P 500 found an average tenure of 4.1 years, the shortest in the core C-suite against 5.0 years for all roles, and 3.5 years at consumer companies. Kimberly Whitler and Neil Morgan spent seven years finding out why and published the answer in Harvard Business Review in 2017: the job descriptions promise growth and deliver communications, so the executive arrives expecting to set strategy and discovers the role is advertising and social media with no say over product, pricing or where the stores open. A fractional brief that makes the same mistake produces the same outcome faster, because there are fewer hours in which to notice.
Why most briefs are a list of channels
Ask a mid-market CEO to write a brief for senior marketing help and the first draft is almost always a job description borrowed from the internet: owns strategy, leads the team, manages agencies, drives pipeline, experienced in SEO, paid, content, email, events and now AI. That document could describe a law firm’s marketing role or a hot tub dealer’s, and it will be read by every candidate as an invitation to say yes to all of it. Whitler and Morgan’s central finding was that there is no widely accepted answer to what a CMO does, so each company invents one, and the invented version is nearly always wider than the authority that comes with it. The executive is measured on revenue and given control of the newsletter.
The fractional version of the mistake has a particular shape. The company wants senior direction without the cost of a full-time executive, which is sensible. It then writes a brief that assumes full-time presence: attend every leadership meeting, manage the team day to day, be available to sales, run the agency, and also set the strategy. Two days a week cannot do all of that, so the fractional leader does the visible parts, which are the meetings and the managing, and the invisible part, which is the deciding, gets done in the car. Gartner found 73% of CMOs already consider their growth expectations high to overly ambitious with a full week. Cut the week to two days and leave the expectations where they were, and the brief has scheduled its own failure.
The five things a brief must settle
The first is the decision. Not “own the strategy” but the specific question the company needs answered in the next two quarters: which of our three segments do we stop serving, whether to replace the agency or the manager, what we say to the market about AI, why the pipeline halved when paid stopped. A brief with one named decision attracts the candidate who has made it before and repels the one who has a framework for making it. The second is authority, in writing: what the fractional leader can decide alone, what needs the CEO, and what is off the table. Whitler and Morgan’s retailer hired a growth CMO and gave him the advertising; a fractional brief that does not name pricing, product and sales as in or out of scope will produce the same surprise in week three.
The third is the number. Pick one that finance already believes and that marketing can move inside the engagement’s life, and state the baseline in the brief so the argument about attribution happens before the contract and not at the review. The fourth is hours and shape: not “two days a week” but which two, whether the leader attends the leadership meeting, and who they manage. The CMO Survey’s finding that headcount growth has halved and training is at 3.8% of spend is a warning here; the brief should say what team actually exists, because a strategist arriving to find one overloaded coordinator will spend the first month doing the coordinator’s job. The fifth is the end. Every fractional engagement ends, and the brief should say what the company expects to have at the end that it does not have now: a hired successor, a working system, a decision made and implemented. The Signal’s earlier piece on hiring authority covers the second item in more depth; this is the list it sits inside.
A brief that lists channels is asking for a marketer. A brief that names a decision is asking for a leader, and the two candidates who reply will not be the same person.
What to leave out
Leave out the skills list. A senior marketer who cannot direct paid search in 2026 does not exist, and asking for it signals that the company wants hands rather than judgment. Leave out years of experience; ask instead for two references from companies within a factor of two of your revenue, because a person who ran a $400 million budget has a lot to unlearn at $20 million and the unlearning happens on your clock. Leave out the culture paragraph. Leave out “AI-native” and its cousins, which describe a tool subscription rather than a capability. Gartner found only 30% of CMOs report mature AI readiness and that the barrier is internal expertise, so the useful question is what the candidate has actually changed in a marketing operation using the tools, with a number attached.
Leave out, above all, the expectation that strategy will be visible on day one. The Spencer Stuart data shows that even full-time CMOs with five-year mandates now move into broader commercial roles or out the door in four, and 9% of the 218 departures they tracked from 2021 to 2025 left to become CEO. A fractional leader is buying the company time to make a decision well, and the brief should protect the first thirty days for diagnosis. A company that wants a campaign in week two should hire an agency; it will cost less and disappoint on schedule.
What you can actually do this quarter
Write the decision in one sentence
Before any candidate conversation, finish this: “In six months I need someone to have decided whether we…” If the sentence will not close, the company is not ready for a fractional leader; it is ready for a conversation about what it wants.
Draw the authority line with the CFO in the room
Three columns: decides alone, decides with CEO, does not touch. Pricing, sales process, product roadmap and headcount all go in a column. The exercise takes an hour and prevents the week-three surprise Whitler and Morgan documented.
State the baseline for the number
Put the current figure, its source and its date into the brief. Qualified pipeline, cost per won deal, share of revenue from new logos. If the company cannot produce the baseline, that is the first deliverable, and it changes who you hire.
Describe the team as it is, not as the org chart says
Names, hours, what each person actually does on a Wednesday. A senior leader will price the engagement on what exists. A brief that overstates the team buys a strategist who spends the retainer on execution.
The part nobody wants to hear
Writing a brief this way requires the CEO to make the decision about what the marketing leader is for before the marketing leader arrives, and the reason most companies hire senior help is precisely that they would rather not. The channel list is comfortable because it defers the choice: hire someone who can do everything, and let them tell us what we should want. That is how a company ends up with a fractional leader running the newsletter, an expectations gap that Gartner measures at 73% of CMOs, and an engagement that ends at the six-month review with everyone agreeing it was a bit unclear.
The companies that get value from fractional leadership are the ones that arrive with a question, give the person the authority to answer it, and accept that the answer might be “stop doing the thing you are proudest of.” That takes a CEO with a spare afternoon and a willingness to be told, and both are rarer than the budget. Strategy belongs to whoever has ten free hours, and the brief is the first ten.
A fractional CMO can only be as clear as the brief, so write the brief as if it were the first decision of the engagement, because it is.
If you are writing a brief right now and want to see how one firm answers it, this is how we run a fractional CMO engagement in Connecticut, and the pricing is on the site so the brief can include a number.