August 10, 2026 · 6 min read

What should a marketing audit actually check before you fire your agency?

41% EFFECTIVE IMPRESSIONS

A marketing audit before you fire your agency checks four things, in this order: where the money actually went, what shipped against what was billed, whether the strategy fit the market you are actually in, and whether the failure sits with the agency or with the brief you gave them. Skip the order and you will fire the wrong party, then rehire the same problem under a new letterhead.

This is not the audit that decides whether to fire your agency. That question got its own answer in an earlier post on this site, Should I fire my marketing agency?, and it is worth reading first if you are still at the maybe stage. This post is about the audit you run once you have decided to look closely, the one that turns a hunch into a case file. Boards want a case file. Hunches are for astrology, not budget reallocation.

/ 01

Follow the money before you follow your gut

Start with spend, not sentiment. The Association of National Advertisers ran an impression-level study of programmatic ad spend with research partners TAG TrustNet and Fiducia and found that only 41% of programmatic dollars reached what the industry calls an effective impression, meaning viewable, free of invalid traffic, and actually delivered to a person in the target audience, in the first quarter of 2025. That is up from 36% in a 2023 benchmark, so the number is moving the right direction. It is also still failing more than half the time.

If nobody on your side can tell you your own effective-impression rate without calling the agency first, that is not proof of agency failure. It is a measurement gap, and closing measurement gaps is the entire point of an audit. Pull the last twelve months of invoices next to the last twelve months of deliverables and reconcile them line by line before you decide who owes whom an apology.

AUDIT SPEND OUTPUT STRATEGY FIT
THE FOUR THINGS A REAL AUDIT ISOLATES BEFORE ANYONE SIGNS A TERMINATION LETTER
/ 02

Deliverables versus the brief you actually gave them

Agency relationships now last longer than they used to, which complicates the story you tell yourself about how bad things have gotten. The ANA and the 4As found that the average client-agency relationship stretched to roughly seven years in 2025, more than double the 3.2 years measured back in 2016. Longer tenure sounds like health. Sometimes it is just inertia wearing health’s clothing, and an audit is how you tell the difference: find the original brief or scope document, and compare it, word for word, to the list of things you are currently angry about. If the agency delivered exactly what was asked and the market moved underneath the brief, that is a strategy problem, not a vendor problem.

Most agency firings are strategy failures wearing an invoice as a disguise.

/ 03

Check whether the agency inherited someone else’s mess

New marketing leaders arrive faster than agencies get replaced. Spencer Stuart’s 2026 CMO tenure study puts average CMO tenure at S&P 500 companies at 4.1 years, while the agency in the room has often been there closer to seven. Do the arithmetic and a meaningful share of the campaigns you are unhappy with were briefed by someone who no longer works at your company. A proper audit separates what the current agency did with the current brief from what a predecessor agreed to under a predecessor’s strategy. Otherwise you are firing the contractor for a blueprint somebody else drew and then walked away from.

41%
of programmatic ad spend reached an effective, viewable, human-seen impression in Q1 2025
ANA / TAG TrustNet / Fiducia · 2025
7.0 YRS
average client-agency relationship length in 2025, up from 3.2 years in 2016
ANA & 4As · 2025
4.1 YRS
average tenure of a chief marketing officer at an S&P 500 company
Spencer Stuart · 2026
7.8%
average marketing budget as a share of company revenue in 2026
Gartner CMO Spend Survey · 2026
The agency now often outlasts the person who hired it. 3.2 YRS AGENCY TENURE 2016 7.0 YRS AGENCY TENURE 2025 4.1 YRS AVG CMO TENURE 2026
SOURCE: ANA & 4AS, CLIENT-AGENCY RELATIONSHIP TENURE REPORT (2025) · SPENCER STUART, CMO TENURE STUDY (2026)
/ 04

What you can actually do this quarter

None of this requires hiring a research firm. It requires a weekend of reading and three honest conversations, done in the right order.

/ 01

Reconcile invoices to deliverables

Pull twelve months of invoices next to twelve months of what actually shipped. Line them up and mark the gaps, not to catch theft, but to see whether the money maps to the plan.

/ 02

Get an outside read on your spend

Ask someone with no stake in your agency relationship to check where your media dollars actually landed, using your own platform data rather than the agency’s summary deck.

/ 03

Reread the original brief

Find the document, email, or slide that started the relationship. Compare it, item by item, to the list of things you are currently unhappy about.

/ 04

Interview three people outside marketing

Ask sales, finance, and operations what “marketing is working” would actually look like to them. Then check whether the agency was ever told that.

/ 05

Set a thirty-day decision clock

Once the audit starts, give yourself a hard deadline to decide. A slow bleed costs more than a wrong call made on time.

/ 05

Why most companies skip the audit and fire on vibes

Everything above takes roughly ten hours: pulling invoices, rereading the brief, running three short interviews, building one clean comparison. Ten hours is not a resourcing problem for a company that can already afford to retain an agency.

The real obstacle is that the ten hours belong to nobody. The marketing leader who could run it has a stake in the answer, because the brief was probably theirs. The CEO who wants it run does not have ten free hours this month, or believes they do not. The agency will not audit itself, whatever the word “partnership” means in its pitch deck. So the decision defaults to whoever complained most recently in a board meeting, and the agency gets fired for the sin of being the most visible line item on the P&L, not necessarily the worst performer on it.

Strategy work in general has this problem. It belongs to whoever has ten free hours, and in a growing company that is functionally nobody. The businesses that get the agency question right treat this audit as a habit, run on a calendar, rather than a breakup ritual performed once, in a bad mood, after a bad quarter.

Run the audit like you intend to keep the agency, and you will find out quickly whether you should.

SOURCES: ANA & 4AS, CLIENT-AGENCY RELATIONSHIP TENURE REPORT (2025) · ANA / TAG TRUSTNET / FIDUCIA, PROGRAMMATIC TRANSPARENCY BENCHMARK (2025) · GARTNER, CMO SPEND SURVEY (2026) · SPENCER STUART, CMO TENURE STUDY (2026)
DFJ
David Fox Jensen
Founder & Principal · The Sentient Marketer

20+ years leading marketing for 150+ brands. Now runs a principal-led fractional CMO and AI consulting practice for mid-market companies. Writes The Signal weekly on what the machines are learning about your business. Machines for scale, never for soul.

Subscribe

Wondering what the machines say about you?