August 28, 2026 · 7 min read

Is our positioning the problem, or is our market shrinking?

Barriers:
85% INTERNAL


Both diagnoses produce identical symptoms, which is why guessing is expensive and why the answer has to come from two numbers rather than from a symptom list. Bain and Company studied 8,000 companies over five years and found that 85% of the barriers executives named to sustained profitable growth were internal and controllable, rising to 94% at the largest firms, with market conditions that offer no growth appearing in the smaller external category.

/ 01

The symptoms are the same under both diagnoses

Flat revenue. Cycles that stretch. More discounting to close what does close. More deals that end with nobody buying anything from anyone. Every article you will find on positioning lists those as the warning signs of a positioning failure, which is true and useless, because they are equally the warning signs of a category that is quietly shrinking underneath you.

Challenger surveyed 667 B2B buyers, most of them on purchases above fifty thousand dollars, and found 38% of purchase processes ended in no deal at all. That is the base rate. A rising no decision share is not by itself evidence of contraction, and it is not by itself evidence that your message stopped landing. It is evidence that something changed, and the diagnosis has to come from somewhere else.

The sequence matters here. Start with the internal evidence and you will find something, because you always do, and the fix will be a repositioning exercise that costs two quarters and lands in a category that has 8% fewer buyers than it had when you started.

85%
Barriers to profitable growth that executives classified as internal and controllable rather than market conditions
Bain and Company, 8,000 companies, 2016
0.8 of 8.7
Points of average annual growth that came from winning share. Market momentum contributed 5.4
McKinsey, The Granularity of Growth
14%
B2B decision makers who see a real difference between suppliers and value it enough to pay for it
CEB Customer Experience Survey, published by Google, October 2013
38%
B2B purchase processes that ended with no deal, the base rate before anything went wrong
Challenger, 667 buyers, 2019
/ 02

Your read on your own market is measurably optimistic

The CMO Survey, run by Christine Moorman at Duke Fuqua with Deloitte and the AMA, asks marketing leaders two questions in sequence: how fast did your largest market grow, and how fast did you grow in it. In Spring 2024 the answers came back at 12.1% and 16.4%. Every respondent, on average, outgrew their own market.

That cannot be true in aggregate. It is arithmetic, not opinion. The gap is a direct measurement of how flattering executive self assessment is on exactly the question you are trying to answer, and it should be the first thing you hold up against your own instinct that the market is tough this year.

The same bias shows up on the other side of the diagnosis. Bain’s work on the delivery gap found 80% of firms believed they delivered a superior customer experience, while 8% of their customers agreed. CEB, in research published by Google, asked 3,000 B2B buyers whether they saw a real difference between suppliers and valued that difference enough to pay for it. Fourteen percent said yes. Note the compound question, because this figure is routinely mangled into a claim that 86% of buyers see no difference at all. The honest version is narrower and worse: they may see a difference, and they will not pay for it.

WHAT LEADERS BELIEVE ABOUT THEMSELVES, MEASURED TWICESELF REPORTED GROWTH12.1%16.4%THEIR MARKETTHEMSELVESCMO SURVEY 2024SUPERIOR EXPERIENCE8%80%CUSTOMERS AGREEFIRMS CLAIMBAIN, 362 FIRMS
Sources: The CMO Survey, Duke Fuqua, Deloitte and the AMA, Spring 2024. Bain and Company, Closing the Delivery Gap, 2005.

Nobody has ever run a positioning workshop and concluded that the positioning was fine. That is not because it always was the problem.

/ 03

Four tests that actually separate the two

Test one, and the only one with an external referent. Compute the size of your category and your revenue as a share of it, per year, for five years. Two numbers, not one. Category shrinking with your share holding is contraction, and repositioning will not fix it. Category flat or growing with your share falling is a positioning problem, and it is live. Both falling is both. The public data exists: Census Bureau Service Annual Survey by industry code, Bureau of Labor Statistics employment projections, trade association shipment data. When newspaper publishing lost 52% of its revenue between 2002 and 2020, that collapse was visible in Census data every single year it was happening.

Test two. Tag twenty four months of closed lost deals by who won. Losing to named competitors is a relative positioning problem, because you were in the room and they were chosen. Losing to no decision is either budget contraction or a failure to make the problem urgent, and you can split that further by asking whether the buyer preferred the status quo or simply could not get their own organisation to agree. Gartner surveyed 632 B2B buyers and found 74% of buying teams showed unhealthy conflict during the decision, which is a stall you can address with proof and enablement rather than with a new tagline.

Test three. Track unbranded category demand over rolling twelve month windows, not quarters. Gartner’s 2026 buyer research found 70% of B2B buyers prefer a completely digital self service purchase and consult around seven information sources. The consideration set now forms before anyone contacts you, so absence from category level demand has stopped being a proxy for a positioning failure and started being a direct measurement of one.

Test four. Take your three most used value claims to ten recent buyers, including three who chose a competitor and three who chose nobody, and ask what you do that others do not. Then open your closest competitor’s website and check whether they could make the identical claim without editing it. If both tests come back uncomfortable, you have your answer, and the 80 against 8 finding above is the reason you cannot run this test on yourselves.

TWO NUMBERS, FOUR DIAGNOSESMARKETCONTRACTIONCATEGORY DOWNSHARE HOLDINGNEITHERKEEP GOINGCATEGORY UPSHARE RISINGBOTHACT FASTCATEGORY DOWNSHARE FALLINGPOSITIONINGIS THE PROBLEMCATEGORY UPSHARE FALLINGCATEGORYSIZEYOUR SHARE OF ITPLOT FIVE YEARS. THE DIRECTION MATTERS MORE THAN THE LEVEL.
Sources: McKinsey, The Granularity of Growth. US Census Bureau Service Annual Survey. Bain and Company, 2016.
/ 01

Pull the category number first

One person, one afternoon, the Census and BLS series for your industry code over five years. Do it before anyone opens a positioning deck, because it is the only input to this diagnosis that does not come from people who work here.

/ 02

Tag closed lost by winner, not by reason

Reason codes are written by the person who lost the deal. Who won is a fact. Competitor losses and no decision losses point at different problems and currently sit in the same bucket on your report.

/ 03

Ask three buyers who did not choose you

Ten minutes each, no pitch, no recording. They will tell you in plain language whether they understood what you did and simply preferred someone else, which is different from never having understood at all.

/ 04

Check the third diagnosis before committing to either

Right strategy, no funding, no machinery. It is the most common finding among companies growing slower than their market and the one least likely to be named out loud in the room.

/ 04

The part nobody wants to hear

There is a third answer and it is more common than either of the two you came in with. The CMO Survey asked companies growing slower than their market to name the cause. Undifferentiated strategy came third at 33.3%. Ahead of it sat underfunding at 42.2% and missing go to market capability at 37.8%. Dead last, at 8.9%, was the strategy was not well designed.

Read that ladder honestly. Underperforming companies rarely have a bad idea. They have a correct idea they never funded and never built the machinery to run, and both of the diagnoses this article started with are more comfortable to say out loud than that one. Blaming the market absolves everyone. Blaming the positioning at least implies a project with a budget and a deck. Admitting that the plan was right and nobody resourced it implicates the people in the room, which is also why it helps to know what companies your size actually spend before anyone calls the number adequate.

The January 2026 edition of the same survey shows how that plays out. When profits come in below expectation, 53.1% of firms move to cutting expenses and 26.8% to growing revenue, and when the cutting starts, marketing goes ahead of other functions 45.4% of the time, rising to 49.9% at B2B product companies. Which means the most common response to a correct but underfunded plan is to defund it further, and then to conclude next year that it did not work.

None of this is a knowledge problem. Every CEO reading this could name the four tests within ten minutes of thinking about it. The tests do not get run because running them takes an unglamorous week that has no deadline attached, and the diagnosis belongs to whoever has that week free, which is nobody. So the company picks the answer that requires the least evidence and moves on, and the two numbers that would have settled it stay unpulled in a public database that costs nothing.

The market either grew or it did not, and that fact has been sitting in a government spreadsheet the entire time you have been arguing about it.

SOURCES: BAIN AND COMPANY, 8,000 COMPANIES, 2016 · THE CMO SURVEY, DUKE FUQUA / DELOITTE / AMA, SPRING 2024 AND JANUARY 2026 · MCKINSEY, THE GRANULARITY OF GROWTH · CEB AND GOOGLE, FROM PROMOTION TO EMOTION, OCTOBER 2013 · BAIN, CLOSING THE DELIVERY GAP, 2005 · CHALLENGER, 667 BUYERS, 2019 · GARTNER, MAY 2025 AND MAY 2026 · US CENSUS BUREAU SERVICE ANNUAL SURVEY
DFJ
David Fox Jensen
Founder & Principal · The Sentient Marketer

20+ years leading marketing for 150+ brands. Now runs a principal-led fractional CMO and AI consulting practice for mid-market companies. Writes The Signal weekly on what the machines are learning about your business. Machines for scale, never for soul.

Subscribe

Wondering what the machines say about you?